Consumer Review Fairness Act Explained
What the Consumer Review Fairness Act and the FTC reviews rule void, forbid and still allow: gag clauses, threats, defamation and confidentiality.
The Consumer Review Fairness Act of 2016 is a US federal law that makes a clause in a standard consumer contract void when it stops a customer from posting an honest review, charges a fee or penalty for doing so, or takes over the customer's rights in the review. A business that offers such a clause breaks the law even if it never enforces it, and the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and state attorneys general can act on it.
The law is narrow on purpose. It does not protect false statements, it does not override confidentiality duties, and it does not stop a business from suing for defamation. A separate FTC rule, the Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials, adds a second layer: since October 21, 2024 it has covered unfounded legal threats, intimidation and knowingly false public accusations aimed at stopping or removing a review.
This article is for businesses and for reviewers: which clauses and tactics are void or risky, what is still lawful, and where the real limits of a reviewer's speech sit. It is information, not legal advice: your own counsel decides, and the sources named below should be read in their current form before anyone acts.
- A non-disparagement clause in a form contract with a consumer is void from the start under 15 U.S.C. 45b, and merely offering it is unlawful.
- Defamation claims, confidentiality duties and a host's right to remove clearly false, private, harassing or unrelated reviews all survive the act.
- Since October 21, 2024, an unfounded or groundless legal threat, intimidation or a knowingly false public accusation made to stop or remove a review is itself an unfair or deceptive practice under FTC rule 16 CFR 465.7.
- Rules abroad differ: Australia's regulator has treated such clauses as likely unfair, while the UK pages read for this guide do not address them.
What the Consumer Review Fairness Act forbids
The act forbids offering a form contract that contains a provision of one of three kinds. It is Section 2 of Public Law 114-258, codified at 15 U.S.C. 45b, and it took effect on December 14, 2016. The void-provision and prohibition rules applied to contracts in effect 90 days later, and the enforcement provisions to contracts in effect one year later, according to the statute's effective-date subsection.
Related readGoogle Reviews Disappeared: Why and What to DoFigures come from 15 U.S.C. 45b and the FTC's question-and-answer page for the reviews rule.
The three kinds of void provision, as the statute describes them:
- A provision that restricts the individual's ability to make a "covered communication", meaning a review or similar assessment of the business's goods, services or conduct.
- A provision that imposes a penalty or fee on the individual for making such a communication.
- A provision that transfers or requires the individual to give up intellectual property rights in the review content, beyond a non-exclusive license for the business to use it.
The FTC's business guidance, Consumer Review Fairness Act: What Businesses Need to Know, reads these plainly. It treats a clause saying a customer will be charged a fee or sued for a negative review as illegal, and does the same for a clause claiming copyright over review text. It adds that businesses should remove such provisions even if they have never used them.
Two points follow. The violation is offering the clause, not only enforcing it, so a dormant clause in a template still counts. And the law concerns contract terms, not what a business may say back: replying to a review is untouched by it. The word "honest" does the work, and the carve-outs below mark where it stops.
Who and what the act covers: form contracts, individuals and reviews
The act applies to a "form contract", which the statute defines as a standardized contract used in selling or leasing goods or services and imposed on an individual without a meaningful opportunity to negotiate. It excludes employer and employee agreements and independent contractor agreements, a point the FTC guidance repeats: the protection is for customers, not for staff or contractors reviewing the company they work for.
The communication protected is broad. The statute covers written, oral and pictorial reviews, and "pictorial" includes photos, video, illustrations and symbols. The FTC guidance says reviews in any forum count, including online reviews, social media posts and uploaded photos or videos, and that evaluations of customer service count as well as product reviews.
Related readRemove a Clutch Review: What Agencies Can DisputeThe clause has to sit in a form contract. An agreement that two parties actually negotiated, such as a settlement between a business and one customer, is a different matter, because the definition turns on whether the contract was imposed without a meaningful chance to negotiate. Whether a term was negotiated is a question of fact for a lawyer.
Why a gag clause in the terms of sale is void, and what that means for each side
A gag clause in a form consumer contract is void ab initio, which means void from the beginning, under 15 U.S.C. 45b(b)(1). The clause never created an obligation the business could enforce, and offering it is unlawful.
For the business, the consequence is exposure, not just an unenforceable sentence. The statute treats a violation as a violation of an FTC rule defining an unfair or deceptive practice, and it gives enforcement to the FTC and to state attorneys general, who may sue in federal district court on behalf of residents. The FTC guidance names financial penalties and a federal court order as possible consequences, and the statute preserves state-law claims.
The FTC's 2019 actions show what this looks like. In June 2019 the FTC announced actions against two companies that used non-disparagement clauses in form contracts, a vacation rental business and a rental management business. As described in the FTC's press release of that month, which could not be re-opened for the final check of this guide:
- One contract set liquidated damages for a customer who left a negative review, and the other form barred applicants from disparaging the company.
- The proposed orders required both to stop using such provisions and to tell affected consumers that the provisions were void and that they could post honest reviews.
For the reviewer, a void clause means signing it did not sign away the right to post an honest review. The statute and FTC pages read do not describe a private lawsuit by consumers, so the enforcers are the FTC and state attorneys general. A reviewer sued on the clause should take legal advice on how to raise its voidness, as this article does not say how a particular court would treat it.
Related readGoogle Seller Ratings: Remove a Review or Fix the StarsWhat stays lawful: defamation, false statements, confidentiality and removal
The act protects honest reviews and nothing more. Section 45b(b)(2) says the voiding rule does not affect duties of confidentiality, claims such as defamation, or the right to remove from its own website content that is clearly false, personal or private, harassing or obscene, or unrelated to the business's offerings. It also leaves untouched a business's right to set terms for commercial photos or video made by its own employees or contractors.
The FTC guidance describes what a business may prohibit or remove in plain terms:
- Reviews that contain confidential or private information, such as financial, medical or personnel details, or trade secrets.
- Reviews that are libelous, harassing, abusive, obscene or sexually explicit, or inappropriate regarding race, gender, sexuality, ethnicity or another intrinsic characteristic.
- Reviews unrelated to the company's products or services.
- Reviews that are clearly false or misleading. The FTC adds that an opinion the business simply disagrees with is unlikely to meet that standard.
There is also a narrow exception for review hosts. Under 45b(b)(3), the voiding rule does not apply to a provision that lets a person who hosts online reviews bar disclosure of things such as trade secrets, private personnel or medical files, certain law enforcement records, unlawful content or malicious code. The exception is for hosts of reviews, not for sellers who want to control what their customers say about them.
So three lawful tools remain for a business that faces a damaging review.
A defamation claim. Defamation means a false statement of fact that harms reputation. In the United States the tests, defenses and deadlines are set by state law and differ by state. An opinion or a true statement is not a basis for a claim, and this article gives no case law because none was read for it.
A confidentiality duty that actually applies. A review that reveals a trade secret, a patient's medical details or another person's private information can be removed. That is different from a general ban on criticism.
Related readRemove a RateMDs Review, and Vitals or WebMD CareA platform request. Review platforms remove content that breaks their own rules, and the act does not stop them. Report the specific rule broken, with evidence, rather than arguing that the review is unfair. For the practical routes when a review truly breaks the rules, see our removal service.
What the FTC reviews rule adds: threats, intimidation and suppression
The FTC's Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials, 16 CFR Part 465, took effect on October 21, 2024. Its section 465.7 reaches conduct the Consumer Review Fairness Act does not: what a business does after a review goes up.
Under 16 CFR 465.7(a), it is an unfair or deceptive practice to use an unfounded or groundless legal threat, a physical threat, intimidation or a public false accusation in response to a consumer review, in an attempt to prevent a review from being written or to cause it to be removed. For a public false accusation, the rule requires knowledge that it was false or reckless disregard for its truth. For removal attempts, the rule applies whether or not the removed review is replaced with other content. Paragraph (a) covers conduct by anyone, not only a business, while paragraph (b) is addressed to a business.
Section 465.1 defines an unfounded or groundless legal threat as one based on claims, defenses or other legal contentions that existing law does not support, or on factual contentions without evidentiary support. The FTC's own question-and-answer page for the rule adds three points:
- Intimidation "is not limited to physical threats". The FTC lists abusive communications, stalking and character assassination as examples when used to force or deter a person.
- Legitimate legal threats are allowed; groundless ones are not.
- Responding publicly to a negative review is allowed, but a business should not knowingly or recklessly make false accusations about the reviewer.
The final rule's preamble, in the Federal Register of August 22, 2024, says the Commission replaced "unjustified" with "unfounded or groundless" to use objective standards.
Related readAI-Generated Fake Reviews and the FTC RuleSection 465.7(b) covers a second tactic, a display decision. It is an unfair or deceptive practice to materially misrepresent that the reviews shown on a site represent most or all submitted reviews when reviews are hidden based on their ratings or negative sentiment. Suppression is excused when a consistent policy applies regardless of sentiment, for example to remove trade secrets, defamatory, harassing or sexually explicit content, personal information, content that is clearly false or misleading, reviews the seller reasonably believes are fake, or reviews wholly unrelated to what it sells.
Can a business sue for a bad review?
A business can sue over a review, but only on grounds that exist apart from a gag clause, and the common ground is defamation. The Consumer Review Fairness Act does not take that right away: its own text says it does not affect claims such as defamation. What it removes is the shortcut of a contract that says "you may not review us" or "a negative review costs you money."
The variants of this question have different answers:
- Sue for an honest negative review. There is little to sue on. A review that states the reviewer's own experience and opinion is what the act protects, and the FTC says a disagreement over opinion is unlikely to count as clearly false.
- Sue for a false statement of fact. This is the case defamation law exists for. Success depends on proof of falsity, the state's tests and the reviewer's defenses, which a lawyer in that state assesses.
- Sue under the non-disparagement clause. For a consumer form contract this fails at the first step, because the clause is void. The FTC's 2019 actions targeted companies that relied on such clauses.
- Sue after threatening to sue. Under the FTC rule, the threat itself can be the problem when it is unfounded or groundless, so a lawyer should check the claim before the letter is written.
Why threatening a reviewer backfires
Threatening a reviewer fails on three levels at once. The legal level is the one above: a groundless threat, intimidation or a knowingly false public accusation can break 465.7, and a clause behind the threat can break the Consumer Review Fairness Act.
The practical level is that threats rarely achieve removal. A review platform removes content that violates its rules, not content the business says is unfair. A threat letter that cites a void clause hands the reviewer a document showing the business tried to silence a customer, and the reviewer is free to post it.
Related readRespond to Patient Reviews Without Breaching PrivacyThe reputational level is the Streisand effect: an attempt to hide information that draws more attention to it. A one-star review read by a few people becomes a story when the business's reaction is shared.
How other countries differ
Rules outside the United States are not a copy of the American act, and only what was read for this guide is stated here: Australia, the United Kingdom and, within the United States, California.
Australia. On June 6, 2018, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) published a media release about a home builder whose standard Home Building Agreement had contained non-disparagement clauses since October 2008, covering over 3,000 customers, and which had relied on them to stop reviews appearing on a review site. The ACCC said standard form terms that stop customers commenting publicly are "likely to be unfair under the Australian Consumer Law". It accepted a court-enforceable undertaking in which the builder admitted the clauses were unfair and agreed not to enforce them or use similar ones. No court ruled on the clauses in that case, so the Australian route is an unfair contract terms analysis, not a ban written for reviews.
United Kingdom. The government's guidance for online review sites, published on September 3, 2025, says review sites must not edit, withhold, remove or delay publication of genuine negative reviews, and must not try to dissuade customers from leaving a review. It does not name a statute in the text read, and it addresses review sites, not clauses in consumer contracts. The pages read on unfair terms, a 2015 guidance update and a 2016 note to wedding venues, did not mention terms that penalize reviews, so this guide makes no claim about whether a gag clause is enforceable in the UK.
Related readCheckatrade Review Dispute: What Can Be RemovedCalifornia. Civil Code section 1670.8 addresses consumer contract terms that waive a consumer's right to make statements about a seller, and threats or enforcement based on them, and it carries civil penalties. The official statute page could not be read for this guide, so no amounts or wording are stated here: read the section on the California Legislature's site before acting. The federal act preserves state-law claims, so a rule like this can exist alongside it.
Decision table: what each clause or tactic means for a business
The table sorts common clauses and tactics by their position under the sources read. It is a map for a conversation with a lawyer, not a ruling on a contract.
| Clause or tactic | Position | Why | Risk level |
|---|---|---|---|
| "No negative reviews" in online terms | Void; offering it is unlawful | Restricts a covered communication in a form contract | High |
| Fee or damages for a bad review | Void; offering it is unlawful | Penalty or fee for making a covered communication | High |
| Letter citing a void clause | Likely a groundless threat | Rule 465.7(a) covers threats without legal support | High |
| Public post accusing the reviewer of lying, knowing it is false | Prohibited | A public false accusation under 465.7(a) | High |
| Hiding negative reviews while showing a "rating" | Prohibited if misrepresented | Rule 465.7(b), unless a neutral policy applies | High |
| Removing a review with private medical or financial data | Lawful | Within the confidentiality and private-information carve-outs | Low |
| Defamation claim over a provably false statement of fact | Lawful route | Not affected by the act; state law decides | Medium, cost and publicity |
| Calm public reply with the business's side | Lawful | The FTC says responding publicly is allowed | Low |
A worked scenario with invented parties
Take Brightwater Moving, an invented local moving company, and Maya, an invented customer. Brightwater's online booking terms include a line saying customers agree not to post negative reviews and that breach carries $5,000 in liquidated damages. Maya books through the form, the crew arrives about four hours late, and a table is damaged. She posts a one-star review that says exactly this. The facts and the sequence are invented to illustrate the rules above, and the dates are only a plausible order of events, not a prediction.
Assumptions: the booking terms are a standard form Maya could not negotiate, she is an individual consumer, her review is honest, and Brightwater's records confirm the late arrival.
- Day 0: the review goes upMaya posts a one-star review describing the late crew and the damaged table. It contains no private data about anyone.
- Day 1: the business reacts with the clauseThe owner emails Maya, cites the terms and demands removal within 48 hours or $5,000. The clause is a form-contract term that restricts a covered communication and penalizes it, so it is void, and a demand built on it has no legal footing.
- Day 2: the reply compounds the problemBrightwater posts publicly that Maya is lying. Its own records show the late arrival, so it knows the accusation is false, the knowledge element of rule 465.7(a).
- Day 3: the reviewer shares the emailMaya posts a screenshot of the demand. The story is now a business that tried to charge a customer for a review.
- Day 4 onward: the better pathA lawyer reviews the situation, the clause is struck from the template, the accusation is withdrawn, and Brightwater apologizes in two sentences and offers to settle the table damage. The review stays beside a professional reply.
Brightwater had lawful tools: a factual reply, a fix for the real damage, and a platform report if Maya had published, say, the crew members' home addresses. It chose tools that the sources read describe as void or prohibited. This article claims no penalty amount for Brightwater's case.
Related readOpenTable Review Removal and Resy: What Venues Can DoWhat a business should do now
- Audit every form. Check booking terms, checkout pages, rental applications, service agreements and any "disclaimers" paragraph for wording that restricts, penalizes or claims rights over reviews, as the FTC guidance advises.
- Remove what is void. Delete the provisions. If customers signed them, the FTC's 2019 proposed orders required notice that the provisions were void, a sensible model for the message.
- Apply one review policy to everyone. Remove reviews only for the neutral reasons above, whatever the rating, which is the lawful form of moderation under 465.7(b).
- Set a reply standard. A short, factual public reply with an offer to fix the real issue, and no accusation the business cannot support.
- Route legal letters through counsel. A letter about a provably false statement of fact is lawful. One about an honest opinion, or built on a void clause, is not.
At Reputation Partners we help people and businesses correct what is inaccurate or unlawful and strengthen what is accurate, and we do not help to silence honest reviews.
Do not send a reply or a legal demand until someone has checked what the review says and what your contract contains. A private audit sorts the removable content from the content that has to be answered, and sets out the lawful route for each. Request a private audit.
Questions people ask
Is a non-disparagement clause ever enforceable against a customer?
In a standard form consumer contract, the act makes it void. Genuinely negotiated agreements, confidentiality duties for private data and trade secrets, and employment or contractor agreements fall outside that rule. Whether a given term is enforceable depends on its facts, so a lawyer should read the actual document.
Can a business ask a reviewer to take a review down?
Asking is not what the rule targets. Rule 465.7(a) addresses groundless legal threats, physical threats, intimidation and knowingly or recklessly false public accusations made to prevent a review or have it removed. A polite message that offers to resolve the complaint sits on the safe side of that line, but pressure, deadlines and penalties for refusing move toward it.
What should a reviewer do after receiving a threat letter?
Keep the original review, the letter, the contract and all messages, and avoid deleting anything. Do not respond with new accusations. Ask a lawyer whether the clause is a void form-contract term, whether the letter is a groundless threat, and whether your state has a procedure for dismissing suits aimed at speech. The FTC and state attorneys general are the enforcers of the federal act.
How large can the penalties be?
The act treats a violation as a violation of an FTC rule, and the FTC says the reviews rule authorizes courts to impose civil penalties for knowing violations. The maximum per violation is adjusted for inflation over time and the pages read for this guide do not state how violations are counted, so check the FTC's current figure before relying on any number.



