We secured our own brand TLD, .reputationpartners. Your brand should too.See how
  1. Reputation Partners
  2. Journal
  3. Reviews

15 min readView as Markdown

Checkatrade Review Dispute: What Can Be Removed

A Checkatrade review dispute follows set rules. See what Checkatrade, MyBuilder and TrustATrader remove, what you can only answer, and how to reply.

A Checkatrade review dispute has two real outcomes: the review is removed because it breaks the platform's rules, or it stays and you answer it in public. Checkatrade, MyBuilder and TrustATrader each publish a short list of removable reviews, and a review you simply think is unfair is not on any of them.

This guide reads the policy pages of the three platforms and sorts each kind of bad review into one of two bins: report it, or reply to it. It says where a page did not answer the question.

The short version
  • Checkatrade and MyBuilder remove reviews that are fake, from someone who did not hire you, or that break content rules, and TrustATrader says it usually filters out false ones. None promises to remove a review because the reviewer is wrong about the quality of the work.
  • Checkatrade also runs a separate Notice and Takedown route for defamation, and wants evidence that a statement is false and harmful.
  • MyBuilder lets you object to any review through its process, but its list of removal grounds is the test it applies.
  • TrustATrader holds negative reviews back and gives the trader a chance to respond before publication.
  • Asking the reviewer to change or delete a genuine review is against Checkatrade's trade guidelines and is the behavior UK consumer guidance warns about.

How the three platforms collect and check reviews

The rules for disputing a review follow from how it got onto the page.

PlatformWho can reviewCheck before publicationTrade's say first
CheckatradeA customer with a genuine experience of the trade; anonymous reviews are not allowedScreened by automated software and checks the platform describes; no pre-publication hold is described on the pages readReply after publication
MyBuilderA homeowner who hired the trade through the platform, once work started or a deposit was paidThe policy does not describe a pre-publication checkReply after publication
TrustATraderA customer of work completed within the last two yearsNegative reviews are held back and investigatedTrader can respond before the review is published (after 14 days)

On Checkatrade, a page on how its reviews work says reviews are checked through SMS, account and platform actions, and that automated software screens them for unusual patterns. In that page's own words, 90 percent of reviews on the site are verified, which is the platform describing itself, not an audit.

MyBuilder is tied to a job. After a hire, the homeowner is prompted to review by email and in-app message, and a review can generally be submitted only if it is linked to a job posted on the platform and the trade was hired through it. The policy also lets a trade collect reviews from up to five customers who hired them outside the platform, verified by a copy of the paid invoice.

TrustATrader works the other way round. Its review page says a review with three or more stars from a customer who recommends the trader counts as positive, while anything lower, a missed appointment or a "not recommended" rating counts as negative. Reviews of work completed more than two years ago are not accepted.

Related readBought a Business With Bad Reviews: What to Do

Checkatrade: what you can report and what stays up

Checkatrade's Where can I view my reviews support page says you can report a review in the Trade App if it is fake, meant for another trade, inappropriate or defamatory, or from a customer you do not recognise. Its review guidelines for trades put a limit on this: only a review that goes against the consumer guidelines can be reported, and the report must be made within three months of publication.

The platform is blunt about the other side. The same support page says, "We won't remove a review simply because you disagree with it." Disagreement, an unfair rating, a customer who exaggerated: all of these are answerable, not removable.

Reviews from someone you do not recognise

This is the most useful route because it turns on a fact you can check. Checkatrade's support page lists a review from a customer you do not recognise as reportable, and the trade guidelines say the platform does not allow anonymous reviews and investigates reviewers a trade does not recognise. The support page that describes the exact evidence step and its time window could not be read for this guide, so do not plan around a fixed number of days.

Before you report, search your own records for quotes, messages, invoices, or a partner or tenant who made the booking. The trade guidelines say continuous or unfounded requests to review negative reviews will not be tolerated, so an unfounded report works against you.

Fake reviews and reviews with guideline breaches

Checkatrade's page on its reviews says a suspected fake leads to a conversation with the trade and removal of the review, that repeated cases can lead to the trade being removed from the platform, and that a specialist team investigates fraud. Its general review guidelines ask reviewers not to use phrases that could harm a trade's reputation, and note that words such as "cowboy", "con artist" and "scammer" may be opinion rather than fact.

Related readGoogle Reviews Disappeared: Why and What to Do

Reviews the reviewer controls

Checkatrade's trade guidelines say the reviewer decides whether to edit, remove or replace a review, even after the issue is resolved, and that the platform does not ask customers to change reviews. A separate Checkatrade support article on managing reviews could not be read for this guide, so its wording on withdrawal is not reported here. Check it before you rely on either page. The safe reading is the strict one: do not plan on a review coming down because you fixed the problem.

Checkatrade defamation claims: the Notice and Takedown route

A review that states false facts can also go through the Notice and Takedown process, which is built for evidence. Checkatrade's guidance for trades defines a defamatory review as one that unfairly harms your reputation or could cause significant financial damage to your business. Its Notice and Takedown page says it assesses whether content is fact-based or opinion-based and whether it meets the legal threshold for defamation.

The Notice and Takedown page lists what a notice should contain: a detailed explanation of why the content is unlawful or breaches policy, the specific URLs, and supporting evidence such as screenshots or documents. For defamation it asks for evidence that the statement is false and harmful. Incomplete notices may be rejected.

The same page says Checkatrade then:

  • acknowledges receipt and reviews the information;
  • temporarily restricts access to the content if necessary;
  • notifies the content originator and asks for a response;
  • makes a final determination and removes or retains the content.

It states that it has sole discretion, that it may not give individual updates, and that opinion and lawful content will not be removed. The page gives no counter-notice procedure and no response or decision deadline, so plan for no news until a decision.

Related readRemove a Clutch Review: What Agencies Can Dispute

MyBuilder: the objection route and its removal list

MyBuilder's reviews policy says a tradesperson may object to any review about them, and that the platform investigates and may remove a review that breaks the terms or the policy. Either party can dispute a review or a reply through the contact form. The policy gives no timeframes for moderation decisions or for investigations.

The practical test is the list of removal grounds. According to the policy, a review is removed when:

  • no work has started and no money has been paid;
  • it does not relate to an authentic job or homeowner on the platform;
  • the homeowner was paid or otherwise incentivised to post it;
  • it contains personal information about anyone;
  • it contains offensive, hateful, racist or derogatory language, or illegal content;
  • it is false, inaccurate or misleading;
  • it conflicts with the platform's terms and conditions;
  • the homeowner asks for removal, or a court order requires it.

The same policy says negative reviews are monitored but not removed unless they breach the terms or the policy, and that removal requests are decided at the platform's sole discretion. "False, inaccurate or misleading" is a wide ground, but you still need to show what is false. "The homeowner asks for removal" means a resolved dispute can end a review on MyBuilder, though pressing a customer to ask is risky (see the CMA section below).

Homeowners can amend their own review by logging in, and deleting one means contacting the platform. MyBuilder's terms were not read for this guide, so the policy is the only MyBuilder source used.

TrustATrader: negative reviews are held and investigated

TrustATrader puts the dispute before publication rather than after it. Its review process page says negative reviews do not appear immediately, the complaints team and the trader are alerted, and the team investigates. It says false reviews are usually filtered out, and that a negative review goes on the profile after 14 days, once the trader has had the option to respond.

Its complaints page lists common results of mediation: the trader fixes the work, offers a goodwill payment, pays another tradesperson to fix it, or the customer leaves a negative review. The review process page says that where the tradesperson puts the problem right, the customer may retract, update or publish the review.

Related readGoogle Seller Ratings: Remove a Review or Fix the Stars

Two limits apply. The pages describe no formal appeal beyond the complaints team's investigation, and they do not say how long an investigation takes. The review process page also describes a strike system: a trader who fails to meet the standards receives a strike, and at three strikes is removed and banned. A trader should treat the first response as the main chance to put evidence on the record.

Removable or only answerable: a decision table

Use this table to sort a review first. It shows what the policies support, not a promised outcome.

The review says or isCheckatradeMyBuilderTrustATrader
From someone with no job or contactReport; investigated, no fixed outcome promisedObject; no work or payment is a removal groundRaised in the held-back check
Fake or for another tradeReport; removal on investigationObject; inauthentic job is a groundFalse reviews are usually filtered out
False statement of factNotice and Takedown with evidenceObject; false or misleading is a groundRespond before publication
Abuse or personal detailsReport as a guideline breachObject; both are groundsNot described on pages read
Harsh opinion about qualityStays; replyStays; replyStays if the facts hold; reply
Fixed and resolvedReviewer's choice; do not askRemovable if homeowner asksCustomer may retract or update

How to reply to a review you cannot remove

A public reply is the one control every platform gives you, so use it even while a report is open. Checkatrade's trade guidelines say replies should be respectful, factual, clear and concise, and that all replies are published unless they break the guidelines. Replies are public, so write each one for a future customer.

A reply that works for the next customer
  1. Read the review twiceSeparate the facts from the feeling. You will answer the facts and acknowledge the feeling.
  2. Check your recordsFind the quote, the dates and the messages before you write. A wrong date gives the reviewer a way to hit back.
  3. Acknowledge, then state the factsSay what you understand the problem to be, then give two or three checkable facts in plain words.
  4. Offer a way to continueInvite the customer to talk through the platform's contact route, and keep the public thread short.
  5. Leave out personal detailsCheckatrade bars full names, addresses and phone numbers in replies, and MyBuilder bars identifying personal information about homeowners, accusatory language and threats.

MyBuilder's policy adds that a reply may not contain promotional material that draws homeowners off the platform, and the platform may remove a reply that breaks the rules. Checkatrade's trade guidelines say content that is obscene, hateful, discriminatory, promotional or spammy will not be published.

What UK law and consumer guidance add

Three primary sources frame these disputes. This is information, not legal advice.

Defamation Act 2013, section 1: serious harm

Section 1 says a statement is not defamatory unless its publication has caused or is likely to cause serious harm to the claimant's reputation. For a body that trades for profit, harm is not serious harm unless it has caused or is likely to cause serious financial loss. That is why a business that wants to sue over a review needs to show real financial effect, not only hurt feelings. Sections 1 and 5 are marked as extending to England and Wales only. Scotland and Northern Ireland have their own defamation law, which was not read for this guide, so a reader there should take advice on local rules.

Related readRemove a RateMDs Review, and Vitals or WebMD Care

Defamation Act 2013, section 5: the website operator defence

Section 5 gives the operator of a website a defence if it shows it did not post the statement. The defence can be defeated in two ways. Either the claimant shows all three of the following: it was not possible to identify the poster, the claimant gave the operator a notice of complaint, and the operator did not respond as the regulations require. Or the claimant shows the operator acted with malice in relation to the posting. A valid notice of complaint gives the complainant's name, sets out the statement and why it is defamatory, and says where on the site it appears. The section also says moderating posts does not by itself defeat the defence.

This mirrors the Checkatrade route, which asks for the explanation, the URL and the evidence. The Defamation (Operators of Websites) Regulations 2013 set out the steps an operator takes after a complaint, but only their headings were read for this guide, so no deadline from them is stated here.

CMA guidance on fake reviews

The Competition and Markets Authority published CMA208, dated 4 April 2025, on the banned practice in paragraph 13 of Schedule 20 to the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024. It covers fake reviews, concealed incentivised reviews and misleading publication of reviews, and it applies to traders as well as to platforms.

For a trade, the guidance says traders should not limit the impact of genuine negative reviews by editing, withholding or removing them. Its examples include threats of harm or legal action, preventing real customers from leaving reviews, and making dispute resolution depend on the consumer not leaving a negative review. For publishers, it describes a duty to take reasonable and proportionate steps to prevent and remove banned reviews. That fits the platforms' firm line on reviews that are only unfair.

Related readAI-Generated Fake Reviews and the FTC Rule

A worked scenario, day by day

This is an invented scenario with generic parties, used to show the order of operations. Assumptions: a Checkatrade member receives a one-star review that describes a job the member cannot match to any quote, message or invoice. The only timing stated is the three-month reporting window.

WhenActionWhat the page says
Day 0Review appears; search quotes, messages, invoices and partner or tenant namesRecords are most useful gathered before you reply or report
Day 1Post a short, calm reply, then use Report Review for an unrecognised customerReports must be made within three months of publication
After the reportAnswer any request for evidence; keep replies factualNo decision time is stated on the pages read
If no real job is foundReview may be removedAnonymous reviews are not allowed
If proof is givenCheck whether it shows a real job; if the facts are false, file Notice and TakedownNotice and Takedown asks for evidence the statement is false and harmful

If the customer shows a real booking, the review stays, so write your Day 1 reply to stay true either way.

What to do next

Sort the review by the decision table, gather the evidence that matches its row, and report or file once with everything attached. Checkatrade's guidelines say continuous or unfounded requests to review negative reviews will not be tolerated.

If this is happening to you now

If several bad reviews have appeared at once, or the same claim is spreading across platforms and search results, a private review of the whole pattern is the quickest way to see which are removable and which need answers. Reputation Partners handles this in a confidential audit.

Questions people ask

Can a Checkatrade trade remove a bad review itself?

No. A trade can reply to a review and can report one in the Trade App, but the platform decides what is removed. Only a review that goes against the consumer guidelines can be reported, and defamation claims can also go through the Notice and Takedown route. Checkatrade's support page says it will not remove a review simply because you disagree with it.

How long do I have to report a Checkatrade review?

Checkatrade's guidance for trades says a report must be made within three months of the review being published. Because policies change, check the guidance page before you rely on that window. Report early, with your records attached, and do not wait to see whether the reviewer changes their mind.

Will MyBuilder remove a review because it is false?

Its reviews policy lists a review that is false, inaccurate or misleading among the grounds for removal, and a trade can object through the process. Removal is still decided at the platform's sole discretion, so state exactly which facts are wrong and attach proof. A review that only criticizes quality is not on the removal list.

Is it allowed to ask the customer to change a review?

Do not ask. Checkatrade's trade guidelines list pressuring or asking reviewers to edit or remove reviews as something trades must not do, and the CMA guidance names threats and conditional dispute resolution as problems. If you fixed the issue, say so in a public reply and let the customer decide. On MyBuilder a customer may amend a review or ask the platform to delete it, and on TrustATrader the customer may retract or update it once the problem is put right.

Can I sue the platform over a defamatory review?

Section 5 of the Defamation Act 2013 gives a website operator in England and Wales a defence if it did not post the statement. The defence can fail if the claimant shows three conditions, including a notice of complaint, or shows malice. That makes the notice route the usual first step. Whether to pursue anyone in court is a decision for your own lawyer, and this guide is information, not legal advice.

What if the review is from a competitor?

A review that does not come from a real customer is removable on all three platforms: Checkatrade bars fake reviews and anonymous reviews, MyBuilder removes reviews unrelated to an authentic job, and TrustATrader says false reviews are usually filtered out. Do not guess at who wrote it. Report the facts that show there was no job and let the platform investigate.

Reputation Partners desk

Notes from the desk. Written by the people who handle the cases.

Tell us what Google says. Quietly.

A partner reads every request personally. Every engagement is quoted individually, after an audit.