Spent conviction news article: how to remove it (UK)
A spent conviction news article can often be delisted but rarely deleted. What the 1974 Act covers, the UK GDPR and ICO routes, and the order to follow.
A conviction that has become spent under the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 does not oblige a newspaper to delete its report or a search engine to drop it. The Act limits what you can be asked and how a spent conviction can be used against you; it does not regulate what is published or indexed. In the UK, the realistic routes to getting a spent conviction news article out of name searches run through data protection law: a delisting request to the search engine, an erasure or anonymisation request to the publisher, and the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO) if either refuses.
Most people assume the 1974 Act already covers an old conviction in search results. It rarely does, and the gap between "spent" and "gone from search" is where most requests go wrong. A request that treats spent status as one strong factor, backed by evidence, has a real chance. One that treats it as a switch is usually refused.
This guide is information, not legal advice: your own solicitor decides what applies to your record.
- Spent status limits questions and legal use of a conviction. It does not require a publisher to delete an article or a search engine to hide it.
- The strongest route is usually a name-search delisting request, where spent status, age and minor nature weigh in your favour. It hides the result for your name only.
- Removal at the publisher is harder, because the journalism exemption can switch off the erasure right, but a correction or anonymisation request is often worth making first.
- If a search engine refuses, the ICO can review the decision. Court action is a last step, taken on advice.
What a spent conviction is and what the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act changes
A conviction becomes spent when its rehabilitation period ends, and the person is then treated as not having committed the offence for most purposes. The core rule is in section 4 of the Act. Evidence of a spent conviction is generally not admissible in proceedings, and the person cannot be required to answer questions that would reveal it. Questions asked outside court are treated as not covering spent convictions, and a spent conviction is not a proper ground for dismissing or excluding someone from an office, profession, occupation or employment. All of this is subject to exceptions, including sections 7 and 8 and orders the Secretary of State can make for specified cases. Some roles and checks are excepted that way, so a spent conviction can still be taken into account for them.
Related readRemove a page from archive.today and other archivesIn England and Wales the period depends on the sentence. Section 193 of the Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Act 2022 amended the table with effect from 28 October 2023, for England and Wales only. For adults, as the legislation.gov.uk text reads, a custodial sentence of more than four years has a period of seven years after the sentence, including any licence, is completed. More than one year up to four years carries four years, and one year or less carries 12 months. A fine carries 12 months from conviction. People under 18 at conviction have shorter periods, and some sentences never become spent, including life sentences and certain long sentences for listed offences.
Source: section 5 of the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 as shown on legislation.gov.uk. Custodial periods run from completion of the sentence including any licence; the fine period runs from conviction. Excluded sentences never become spent. Check the current table before relying on a figure.
What the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act does not do online
The Act contains no power to order a newspaper, a website or a search engine to remove spent-conviction content. Section 4 speaks to legal proceedings, questions and employment-type decisions, not publication, archives or indexing. Unlock, the UK charity for people with convictions, advises asking the publisher to remove the reference first, and describes a defamation claim, which needs proof of malice, as very difficult.
The Act touches publishers in one place: defamation. Section 8 deals with libel and slander actions (defamation actions in Scotland) brought by a rehabilitated person over a publication suggesting they committed or were convicted of an offence that is now spent. Three points matter.
- If the publication happened before the conviction became spent, the section 4(1) protection does not affect the action at all.
- A publisher relying on the truth defence in section 2 of the Defamation Act 2013 loses it only if the publication is proved to have been made with malice. An accurate report is not defamatory just because the conviction later became spent.
- The fair and accurate report defence is lost if the publication referred to evidence ruled inadmissible under section 4(1), with limited exceptions for bona fide law reports and educational or professional reports.
England and Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland: what differs
The three UK legal systems share a model but not the detail. The ICO covers all three, because data protection law is UK-wide, but the rehabilitation rules and defamation statutes are not.
Related readRemove Your Name From Justia, Casetext and Case Sites| Nation | Rehabilitation law | Wording and example (adult) | Defamation link |
|---|---|---|---|
| England and Wales | 1974 Act, section 5, amended from 28 October 2023 | "Rehabilitated person". Custodial sentence of one year or less: 12 months after completion | Section 8, with the Defamation Act 2013 |
| Scotland | Same Act, with sections 5A onward inserted by the Management of Offenders (Scotland) Act 2019 from 30 November 2020 | "Protected person" and "disclosure periods". Custodial sentence up to 12 months: the term plus two years. A fine: 12 months | Section 8 applied to defamation, with the Defamation and Malicious Publication (Scotland) Act 2021 |
| Northern Ireland | Rehabilitation of Offenders (Northern Ireland) Order 1978, Article 6 | Imprisonment of six months or less: 7 years. A fine or unlisted sentence: 5 years | Article 9, with the Defamation Act (Northern Ireland) 2022 |
A comparable sentence can be spent in one nation and live in another, because the Northern Ireland periods in the examples are longer. The 2023 changes apply to England and Wales only. The Northern Ireland Order carried amendments not yet applied in the version read, so check the current text.
How a search engine treats a spent conviction news article
A search engine is a separate controller of personal data, so you can ask it to delist a result without touching the article. Delisting removes the result for searches on your name; the page stays online. The ICO's guidance on internet search results says so: use the provider's form, on the basis that the result is significantly affecting your privacy rights. The provider must consider the request but does not have to agree, and it is good practice to explain a refusal.
The ICO publishes search result delisting criteria that it applies when a refusal comes to it. The ones that matter for a spent conviction news article are:
- whether you have a public role, such as a senior official, business person or regulated professional;
- whether the result is accurate and still current;
- whether it concerns working or private life;
- evidence that the result is causing prejudice, which the ICO treats as a strong factor for delisting, though you need not prove it; and
- the weight of journalism and freedom of expression.
On criminal offences the ICO does not use the phrase "spent conviction". It refers to public policy on rehabilitation, says delisting is more likely for relatively minor offences committed long ago and less likely for serious or recent ones, and decides each case on its facts.
Google's page on removal requests under European privacy law says it looks to local rules on when a conviction becomes spent or expunged, asks whether continued display is strictly necessary for freedom of information, and weighs the age of the content and the public interest, giving weight to journalists' editorial judgments, especially for recent material. It weighs these factors together and treats none as decisive. The page describes European requests, so check the UK form's current wording. Other search engines run their own forms, and each needs its own request.
Related readSomeone Registered My Name as a Domain: What to DoThe leading UK case is NT1 and NT2 v Google, decided by Mr Justice Warby on 13 April 2018 under the Data Protection Act 1998, before the UK GDPR. Both claimants had spent convictions. NT1, convicted of a business-related conspiracy, lost: the information stayed relevant to his continuing business career and he had not accepted his guilt. NT2, who pleaded guilty to conspiracy and whose conviction became spent in 2014, won a delisting order. The court treated spent status as relevant but not decisive, and also weighed the nature of the offence, remorse, risk of repetition, current activity and how out of date the information was.
A warning comes from the ICO's own history. In August 2015 it ordered Google to remove nine links to news stories about an earlier removal, which had brought a spent conviction for a minor offence back into results. Publicity about your own request can itself become a search result.
Sources: section 193 of the Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Act 2022 on legislation.gov.uk; the ICO's public guidance on erasure and on internet search results.
Erasure at the publisher: where the journalism exemption stops
A request to the publisher can ask for the article to be corrected, updated, anonymised or deleted, and the UK GDPR gives you a formal basis to ask. The ICO's public guidance says an organisation has one calendar month to respond, with up to two further months in some cases if it explains why within the first month. It also lists reasons to refuse, the first being that keeping the data is needed for freedom of expression, including journalism.
That reason is built into the Data Protection Act 2018. Paragraph 26 of Schedule 2 disapplies the erasure right in Article 17(1) and (2), and many other UK GDPR provisions, for processing for journalistic, academic, artistic or literary purposes. The ICO's guidance on applying the journalism exemption sets out the conditions. The publisher must be processing for a journalistic purpose with a view to publication, must reasonably believe publication is in the public interest, and must reasonably believe that complying with the provision would be incompatible with its journalistic purpose. It must give special weight to freedom of expression and consider relevant codes, including the Editors' Code of Practice.
Related readAsk a Publisher to Anonymize Your Name in an Old ArticleThree limits are worth knowing, because a standard refusal can overreach.
- The exemption is not automatic. It applies to the extent the publisher reasonably believes erasure would be incompatible with journalism, and the publisher must be able to show that belief.
- It does not extend to search engines. In NT1 and NT2, decided under the 1998 Act, the court found Google could not rely on the journalism exemption: it did not process the data for journalistic purposes and offered no evidence that compliance would be incompatible with journalism. The ICO's delisting criteria likewise say the law protects journalistic activity in ways not available to search engines.
- It is not specific about archives. The guidance covers activity before and after publication, but the page read for this guide gives no archive-specific rule and says it is under review following the Data (Use and Access) Act. An old report in an online archive is a judgment call, not a settled rule.
For comparison, the European Court of Human Rights held in Hurbain v Belgium (Grand Chamber, 4 July 2023) that ordering a newspaper to anonymise the online version of a 1994 article, while the print archive stayed intact, did not violate freedom of expression. It is a Belgian case, not a UK ruling, but it shows why anonymisation is a better ask than deletion.
When an IPSO complaint fits
The press regulator route is for inaccuracy, not for age. IPSO, the regulator for its member publications, considers complaints under the Editors' Code, and Clause 1 covers accuracy. The Code itself could not be read for this guide, so check its clauses before filing; a complaint that an accurate article is merely old is a poor fit for an accuracy route.
A complaint can fit where the article states the sentence wrongly, confuses two people, or omits a later quashing or reduction. On IPSO's page, complaints are generally accepted within four months of publication, and material still online may be considered within 12 months. Remedies the publication may offer include corrections, apologies and removing articles. IPSO does not ordinarily consider complaints while the parties are in active legal correspondence about the material, so sequence matters. Making a complaint is free.
Only member publications are covered, and the ICO does not regulate press accuracy. Check which regulator, if any, the publisher belongs to.
Which route fits which situation
The right route for an old, accurate, minor conviction is rarely the right one for an inaccurate report.
Related readRemove an Article From Google News: What Works| Route | What it can change | Speed and cost level | Main risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Publisher request (correct, anonymise, delete) | The page itself, if the publisher agrees | Weeks, often no reply. Low cost | Refusal under the journalism exemption, or a new story about your request |
| Search engine delisting request | Results for your name on that engine only | About a month for a first answer. Low cost | Refusal where the offence is serious, recent or tied to a public or professional role |
| Complaint to the ICO after a refusal | Can tell the search engine to act, where appropriate | Unlock reports around 29 weeks just for a case to be assigned | Slow; no compensation; the ICO may decide not to act |
| IPSO complaint | Corrections, apologies, sometimes removal, for inaccuracy | Four-month window, then weeks to months. No cost to file | Does not fit articles that are accurate but old |
| Court claim (data protection, privacy, defamation) | Delisting, correction or damages, by order | Months to years. High cost | Cost, publicity and the risk of losing, as NT1 did |
Suppression is a different category: it moves accurate, better pages above the old report without removing anything. It is covered on the suppression service page and is the fallback when removal routes fail.
The order of operations that avoids the usual mistakes
Establish facts first, then ask the party that can fix the source, then the search engines, then the regulators. In our experience, requests sent in the wrong order usually produce refusals that cite each other.
- Confirm the conviction is spentWork out the sentence, its completion date including any licence, and the period for your nation. If it is unspent or excluded, delisting is much harder and the argument changes.
- List every page and copyRecord the original article, copies, archive pages and later stories, with the date and URL of each.
- Mark errors and outdated pointsNote anything inaccurate, any later outcome the article omits, and anything about your current life that shows rehabilitation. These carry the argument.
- Ask the publisher for the smallest fix firstRequest correction, an update line or anonymisation, citing data protection law, and state what you would accept. Keep the tone factual.
- File name-search delisting requestsUse each search engine's own form. Cite the spent status, the age, the nature of the offence and the evidence of harm, and the ICO's delisting criteria.
- Escalate refusals in writingComplain to the controller first, then to the ICO. For a plain accuracy problem, consider IPSO within its time limits.
- Take advice before any court stepA claim carries cost and publicity risk, so a solicitor should assess it, including the section 8 limits and the procedure in your nation.
Make no public statement, post or press approach about the request, because a new article about a removal attempt is a new search result, as the 2015 ICO notice shows. Never contact journalists or complainants in a way that could look like pressure.
A worked scenario with invented parties
Take an invented case. Jordan Hale lives in England and was convicted of fraud by false representation, with a sentence of ten months in custody. A regional paper, the Fenwick Chronicle, published a court report, and a site that copies local crime stories, Crimedesk Archive, reposted it. At Month 23, a name search on Jordan returns the Chronicle report on page one.
Assume the conviction came after 28 October 2023, the sentence including licence ended at Month 10, and the 12-month period for a custodial sentence of one year or less applies. This is a scenario, not a real case, and the dates are illustrative.
| When | Step | Assumption or typical outcome | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Month 0 | Conviction and sentence | Ten months in custody | Court report published |
| Month 10 | Sentence and licence end | Assumed date | Rehabilitation period starts |
| Month 22 | Conviction becomes spent | 10 months plus 12 months | Spent in England and Wales |
| Month 23 | Requests to the Chronicle and search engines | Update line and anonymisation; delisting for name searches | Usually no reply or a refusal from the paper at first; about a month for the engines |
| Month 25 | Complaint to the controller, then the ICO | Only for a refused request | Slow; no compensation |
The Chronicle replies after several weeks that the report is accurate and declines to change it. Jordan does not argue the point. The delisting requests set out that the conviction became spent at Month 22, that it was a single non-violent offence, that there has been no further offending, and that Jordan now works in an unrelated trade. They do not claim the Act requires removal. They ask each engine to weigh the factors it uses.
Related readRemove explicit images from Bing and other search enginesSuppose the first engine delists the Chronicle result for Jordan's name and the second refuses because the offence involved dishonesty and Jordan is applying for roles in financial services. That is where NT1 is relevant: an offence connected to a current career can weigh heavily against delisting. Jordan complains to the controller and then to the ICO, and asks Crimedesk Archive, a separate controller, to take its copy down. The result is mixed, a typical shape: one engine delisted, one refusal under review, the original page unchanged and a copy gone.
When none of these routes works, and what to do instead
A conviction that is not yet spent, or never becomes spent, gets little help from the rehabilitation argument. Serious or recent offences, offences tied to a current public or professional role, and cases where the person has not accepted responsibility are all weak. NT1 failed on the last two.
When removal is not available, there is a lawful alternative that hides nothing: publish accurate, current information about your work and life on pages you control, so that the first page for your name reflects who you are now. That is suppression, and it works over months, not days. It does not conceal the underlying record, which stays accessible to anyone who looks. At Reputation Partners we treat no route here as a promise.
What to do next
Confirm that the conviction is spent and under which nation's rules, then choose the route that fits.
Do not post about it or contact the journalist yet. Gather the sentence details, the dates and every URL that shows the conviction, then have the file looked at before the first request goes out. A private audit maps the pages, the likely route and the risks in order.
Questions people ask
Does a spent conviction have to be deleted from a news website?
No. Nothing in the 1974 Act requires a publisher to delete or edit a report. A publisher can be asked to correct, update or anonymise the article using data protection law, and may refuse by relying on the journalism exemption. A refusal is not the end if the article is inaccurate, but an accurate report of a real conviction usually stays unless the publisher agrees to change it.
Related readRemove an Attack Website About You: Four RoutesCan I ask a search engine to hide a conviction that is not yet spent?
You can ask, because the request rests on data protection law and not on the Act. But the ICO says delisting is less likely for serious or recent offences, and an unspent conviction usually weighs against you. Strong arguments would be inaccuracy, your age at the time, or a minor offence long ago. Expect a refusal unless one of those applies.
Why does an old conviction still appear after a successful delisting request?
Delisting removes the result for searches on your name from that search engine only. The page can still appear for other queries, on other engines that have not delisted it, and on copies hosted elsewhere. Each engine and each copy is a separate request. A result can also return if the page changes address, so a periodic check is part of the job.
Can I sue a newspaper for reporting my spent conviction?
Section 8 of the 1974 Act limits what defamation claims can do. A truthful report can still rely on the truth defence unless the publication is proved to have been made with malice, and if the report was published before the conviction became spent, the Act's protection does not affect the claim at all. That makes defamation a narrow route. A data protection or private information claim is a different action. Take advice from a solicitor in your nation.
Will an employer see my spent conviction in a search?
An employer can run a name search, and the 1974 Act does not stop that. It does limit what the employer can ask you and what it can lawfully treat as a ground for dismissal or exclusion, subject to excepted roles. Ask your adviser how this applies to the role you want.
How long does the whole process take?
The first answer from a search engine or publisher is usually due within about a month. If a request is refused and goes to the ICO, Unlock reports that an ICO case can take around 29 weeks just to be assigned, so a full cycle can run past a year. A court claim takes longer. Plan in months.



